Top Rated CPAs in New Albany, IN (2026)
Choosing the right cpa in New Albany, IN can be overwhelming. With 8 cpas operating across the New Albany metro area, how do you separate the truly exceptional from the merely adequate? At Top CPAs, we analyze publicly available data to rank every cpa on a transparent, editorial basis -- no paid placements, no sponsored rankings.
This 2026 ranking evaluates cpas in New Albany, Indiana using aggregate customer ratings across Google and verified review platforms. We reviewed 8 active businesses in the New Albany market and selected the top 8 for this list.
By the numbers: Guide Score percentages on this list range from 40% to 66%, 3 of 8 hold professional certifications, the average firm has 28 years of experience. Updated June 2026.
Each entry below includes the business's Guide Score, star rating, review count, and a data-driven explanation of why they earned their spot. Click through to any profile for the full breakdown including contact information, specialties, credentials, and related businesses in New Albany.
The Top 8 CPAs in New Albany, IN
-
#1 Monroe Shine & Co 66%
Selected for CPA certified; specializes in tax preparation planning, audit assurance, outsourced accounting.
Monroe Shine & Co is an accounting firm serving New Albany, IN. Contact them at +18129452311 or visit their website to learn more about their services.
View full profile → -
#2 The Haynes Company 65%
Selected for 28 years of experience (est. 1998); specializes in services, share testimonial, learn irs resources financial calculators.
Serving homeowners and businesses in New Albany, The Haynes Company is an dependable accounting firm in IN. Reach them at +15028938120 or email info@thehaynescompany.com. Visit their website to learn…
View full profile → -
#3 DMLO CPAs 64%
Selected for CPA certified.
DMLO CPAs, an accounting firm based in New-Albany, IN, welcomes inquiries at 8129494085 and through their website.
View full profile → -
#4 Harvest CPA, LLC 61%
Selected for CPA certified.
Harvest CPA, LLC is an accounting firm based in New Albany, IN, dedicated to delivering quality accounting services. Stephanie has been passionate about public accounting since beginning her career i…
View full profile → -
#5 Grube CPA 60%
Selected for specializes in tax preparation and filing, business services, tax planning.
Grube CPA is an accounting firm based in New Albany, IN, dedicated to delivering quality accounting services. Located at 5150 Charlestown Rd. Reach them at +18129135362. Visit their website for more…
View full profile → -
#6 Davidson & Company, CPAs 49%
Ranked 6th among cpas in this market based on overall Guide Score.
Looking for an accounting firm in New Albany? Davidson & Company, CPAs serves the greater New Albany metropolitan area. Call +18129447677 or visit their site for details.
View full profile → -
Ranked 7th among cpas in this market based on overall Guide Score.
Indiana Business Appraisals LLC serves New Albany and surrounding IN communities with professional accounting services tailored to each client's needs. Located at 145 E Elm St. Reach them at 81259041…
View full profile → -
#8 Cason Financial Services 40%
Ranked 8th among cpas in this market based on overall Guide Score.
You can find Cason Financial Services, an accounting firm serving New Albany, IN, at 1934 E Spring St. Stop by or call to learn more.
View full profile →
How We Ranked These CPAs
This list ranks cpas by their aggregate customer rating (Google and verified review platforms). Ties are broken by Guide Score. Only businesses with at least one verified review are eligible.
Data sources include Google Business Profile, professional registries, portfolio sites, press databases, and direct business submissions. Every piece of data is publicly verifiable.
Frequently Asked Questions
How did we rank the best cpas in New Albany?
Top CPAs ranks cpas using our Guide Score percentage, a composite metric computed from publicly available data. The score uses weighted evidence from ratings, review volume, web presence, profile completeness, credentials, press recognition, and experience, then normalizes across categories where positive evidence was captured. Categories with no captured signal are not counted as failing grades. There is no paid placement -- every ranking is purely editorial.
Who is the #1 cpa in New Albany, IN?
As of 2026, Monroe Shine & Co holds the #1 ranking in New Albany with a Guide Score of 66%. Rankings are recalculated with every data update and reflect the latest available information.
How often is this list updated?
Core data (ratings, reviews, contact information) is re-verified on a rolling monthly cadence. Credentials and awards are audited quarterly. Guide Scores recalculate automatically with every data update, so rankings may shift as new reviews are posted or credentials are verified.
How many cpas are there in New Albany?
Our database currently tracks 8 active cpas in the New Albany, IN metro area. This list highlights the top 8 based on Guide Score. Browse our full New Albany directory to see every listed business.
Can a cpa pay to be ranked higher?
No. Top CPAs does not accept payment for rankings. Guide Scores are computed algorithmically from verified public data. Businesses can claim and update their profile with accurate information, but the ranking algorithm treats all profiles equally. Our editorial independence is core to our methodology.
What should I look for when hiring a cpa in New Albany?
We recommend evaluating: (1) professional certifications and credentials, (2) verified customer reviews and ratings, (3) years of experience in the New Albany market, (4) portfolio quality and range of work, (5) budget alignment with your project scope, and (6) responsiveness and communication style. Our Guide Score weighs these factors so you can compare at a glance.