Best CPAs in New Albany, IN — 2026 Rankings

We ranked 8 CPA and accounting firms in New Albany based on credentials, client reviews, press recognition, and professional presence.

Top CPAs in New Albany

  1. #1 — Monroe Shine & Co Score: 27/100

    Top Louisville & Indiana CPA Firm | Tax & Business Consulting

    Services: Tax Preparation Planning, Audit Assurance, Outsourced Accounting, Consulting Strategy, Wealth Management Services, Search Site Search our site Find Call Us (800) 238 0135 Client Portal Payments Monroe Shine Services Tax Preparation Planning, Employee Benefit Plans, Industries Construction, Auto Dealerships, Manufacturing Distribution, Real Estate, Financial Institutions, Non Profit, Rural Cooperatives, News Community, Locations, Careers Job Openings, Experienced Professionals, College Students, College Scholarships, Services Tax Preparation Planning, Business Tax, Individual Tax, Estates and Trusts, State and Local Tax (SALT), Cost Segregation Studies, Credits and Incentives, Audits, Reviews Compilations, Internal Audit, Agreed Upon Procedures. View full profile →

  2. #2 — The Haynes Company Score: 26/100

    Serving homeowners and businesses in New Albany, The Haynes Company is an dependable accounting firm in IN. Reach them at +15028938120 or email info@thehaynescompany.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 1201 Lexington Dr.

    Services: Services, Share Testimonial, Learn IRS Resources Financial Calculators, Record Retention Guide, IRS Publications, IRS Forms, Tax Appointment Checklist, Tax Rates, Tax Due Dates, Taxpayer Rights, Tax Glossary, IRS Withholding Calculator, Where is My Refund?, Haynes Company Resources, Collaborate Client Portal, Make a Payment, Accounting Software Selection Implementation, Bookkeeping/Write Up, Business Consulting, Business Entity Selection, Buying or Selling a Business, Financial Analysis, Financial Statements, IRS Representation, Management Advisory Services, Payroll Services, Tax Preparation Planning. View full profile →

  3. #3 — Harvest CPA, LLC Score: 25/100

    Harvest CPA

    Services: General Accounting. View full profile →

  4. #4 — Russ and Associates Accounting Services Score: 23/100

    Welcome | Russ and Associates Accounting & Tax Specialists

    Services: Profile, Services, Resources Financial Calculators, Record Retention Guide, IRS Publications, IRS Forms, Tax Appointment Checklist, Tax Rates, Tax Due Dates, Taxpayer Rights, Tax Glossary, IRS Withholding Calculator, Where is My Refund?, Request Appointment, Share Testimonial, OUR PORTAL, Tax Forms, Accounting Software Selection Implementation, Bookkeeping/Write Up, Business Consulting, Business Entity Selection, Buying or Selling a Business, Financial Analysis, Financial Statements, IRS Representation, Management Advisory Services, Payroll Services, Retirement Planning, Sales Tax Services, Tax Preparation Planning. View full profile →

  5. #5 — Grube CPA Score: 21/100

    Grube CPA is an accounting firm based in New Albany, IN, dedicated to delivering quality accounting services. Located at 5150 Charlestown Rd. Reach them at +18129135362. Visit their website for more details on services and portfolio.

    Services: TAX PREPARATION AND FILING, BUSINESS SERVICES, TAX PLANNING, FINANCIAL REVIEW, BUSINESS SETUP AND ORGANIZATION (ENTITIES), ESTATE, TRUST, GIFT TAX FORMATION, AND FILING, NON PROFIT (501(C)(3)) SETUP AND TAX PREPARATION, FORENSIC SERVICES, QUICKBOOKS SETUP AND TRAINING, Services, Tax Resolution, PORTAL LINK, From bookkeeping to financial statement preparation and payroll management, we offer essential financial support to help your business thrive., Plan for your financial future with our strategic tax planning services, designed to minimize tax liabilities and maximize your financial well Being., Gain insights into your financial health through our comprehensive financial reviews, where we provide recommendations for improvement., Let us assist you in choosing the right legal entity and organizational structure to meet your business goals., Our expertise extends to estate planning, trust creation, and gift tax matters, ensuring your assets are managed according to your wishes., For non Profit organizations, we offer support in obtaining tax Exempt status and provide ongoing tax preparation services to maintain compliance., In cases of financial irregularities or fraud, our forensic services can help uncover and resolve financial misconduct., Simplify your financial record Keeping with our QuickBooks setup and training services, making managing your finances more efficient.. View full profile →

  6. #6 — Zimmerman Boltz & Co Score: 20/100

    Dental Practice Accounting Advisors

    Services: General Accounting. View full profile →

  7. #7 — Davidson & Company, CPAs Score: 17/100

    Looking for an accounting firm in New Albany? Davidson & Company, CPAs serves the greater New Albany metropolitan area. Call +18129447677 or visit their site for details.

    Services: General Accounting. View full profile →

  8. #8 — Indiana Business Appraisals LLC Score: 16/100

    Indiana Business Appraisals LLC serves New Albany and surrounding IN communities with professional accounting services tailored to each client's needs. Located at 145 E Elm St. Reach them at 8125904155. Visit their website for more details on services and portfolio.

    Services: General Accounting. View full profile →

How We Rank CPAs & Accounting Firms

Our Guide Score (0–100) combines Google rating (35%), review volume (20%), web and portfolio presence (20%), profile completeness (15%), professional credentials like CPA/EA/CMA (5%), press recognition (3%), and years of experience (2%). Read our full methodology →

Frequently asked questions

Who is the #1 CPA in New Albany?
Monroe Shine & Co is currently the #1 ranked CPA firm in New Albany based on our Guide Score, which evaluates Google reviews, credentials, press recognition, and professional presence. See the full ranked list above.
How are CPAs ranked in New Albany?
Our Guide Score (0–100) combines Google rating (35%), review volume (20%), web and portfolio presence (20%), profile completeness (15%), professional credentials like CPA/EA/CMA (5%), press recognition (3%), and years of experience (2%). There is no paid placement.
What do CPAs typically charge in New Albany?
Pricing varies by service and firm size. Individual tax returns in New Albany commonly range from $200–$800; small business accounting packages run $500–$3,000/month; audit and advisory engagements are typically quoted per project. Each firm's profile page lists available services and contact information for quotes.