Best CPAs in Staten Island, NY — 2026 Rankings
We ranked 41 CPA and accounting firms in Staten Island based on credentials, client reviews, press recognition, and professional presence.
Top CPAs in Staten Island
-
#1 — Arlia & Associates CPAs Score: 100%
Arlia & Associates – Your Bridge to a Positive Future
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#2 — ECB Consulting, Inc. Score: 100%
ecbtax.com – 20 ani de rigoare contabilă. Acum și AI
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#3 — Barris Associates Ltd. Score: 100%
Staten Island, NY Tax and Accounting Services
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#4 — DeSantis, Kiefer, Shall & Sarcone, LLP Score: 100%
Full Service Accounting Firm
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#5 — Accounting, Tax, & Audit Services Score: 98%
Tax Services Staten Island NY
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#6 — De Rosa and De Rosa Score: 97%
Michael DeRosa Accounting
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#7 — iTax Solutions Score: 97%
iTax Solutions: Providing High Quality Accounting Services
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#8 — Manning Accounting Services Score: 97%
Accounting Services
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#9 — David C. Egan, CPA Score: 94%
Staten Island, New York Accounting Firm | Home Page
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#10 — CSI GROUP, LLP. - CPAs Score: 94%
CSI Group CPA
Services: Tax Preparation, Financial Retirement Planning, Estate Planning, Business Services, Services Tax Preparation, Locations New Jersey, New York, More Mergers, Join Our Team, Forms, Client Portal, Disclosure. View full profile →
-
#11 — Del Rey, Tanzi, Guglietta, D’Ambrosi, CPAs, LLP Score: 94%
Del Rey, Tanzi, Guglietta, D'Ambrosi, CPAs, LLP Account Firm Staten Island, NY
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#12 — John C. D'Angelo Score: 94%
John D'Angelo CPA
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#13 — ATAX Dongan Hills, NY Score: 92%
ATAX Tax Preparation Services In Dongan Hill, NY
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#14 — David Valvik CPA PLLC Score: 91%
Home | Staten Island, Manhattan and Brooklyn Accounting, Tax Preparation and Business Advisory
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#15 — Accounting, Tax, & Audit Services Shibu P. Thomas. MBA, MS Score: 90%
Tax Services Staten Island NY
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#16 — Goldenthal & Suss Consulting Score: 89%
Staten Island, New York Accounting Firm | Home Page
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#17 — About Profit Score: 89%
About Profit NJ Accounting
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#18 — Gabor and Associates Score: 89%
Local Accounting Firm | Tax Law Firm
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#19 — Doreen M Inserra CPA PC Score: 89%
Doreen M Inserra CPA PC
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#20 — Nataliya Lindvor CPA PC Score: 81%
Nataliya Lindvor CPA PC is an accounting firm serving Staten Island, NY. Contact them at 3479938544 or visit their website to learn more about their services.
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#21 — Karpicki Zanelotti Associates Score: 77%
The Staten Island, NY area is home to Karpicki Zanelotti Associates, an dedicated accounting firm serving local clients. Reach them at +17189484465 or email scottlow@martechgroup.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 4017 Richmond Ave.
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#22 — Maria Taber EA Score: 76%
Maria Taber
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#23 — Halbreich Accounting and Tax Services Score: 74%
Halbreich Accounting and Tax Services serves Staten Island and surrounding NY communities with professional accounting services tailored to each client's needs. Located at 18 Bradley Ave. Reach them at +17189829057. Visit their website for more details on services and portfolio.
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#24 — Carbonella & Company LLP Score: 71%
Carbonella & Company LLP is an accounting firm serving Staten Island, NY. Contact them at 7182271435 or visit their website to learn more about their services.
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#25 — Victory Tax Score: 71%
Victory Tax – Be A Winner This Tax Season
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#26 — NPM and Associates Score: 69%
As an accounting firm in Staten Island, NPM and Associates works with clients across the NY region. Reach them at +16466571543 or email info@npmandassociates.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 54 Boone St.
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#27 — Bonfiglio & Dietz Score: 66%
Bonfiglio & Dietz delivers personalized accounting solutions to clients throughout Staten Island, NY. Reach them at +17183709779 or email chris@bdcpatax.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 900 South Ave.
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#28 — Michael J Fulmino CPA Score: 66%
Michael J Fulmino CPA delivers personalized accounting solutions to clients throughout Staten Island, NY. Reach them at +19176994984 or email michael@mfulminocpa.com. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 12 Bryson Ave.
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#29 — John J Vento, CPA, P.C. Score: 54%
John J Vento, CPA, P.C. is an accounting firm serving Staten Island, NY. Contact them at 7189809000 or visit their website to learn more about their services.
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#30 — Charles Reilly Score: 54%
Serving homeowners and businesses in Staten Island, Charles Reilly is an dependable accounting firm in NY. Reach them at 3475989416. Visit their website to learn more about their work. Located at 55 Lindenwood Rd. Reach them at 3475989416.
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
How We Rank CPAs & Accounting Firms
Our Guide Score percentage combines Google rating (35%), review volume (20%), web and portfolio presence (20%), profile completeness (15%), professional credentials like CPA/EA/CMA (5%), press recognition (3%), and years of experience (2%), then normalizes across captured positive categories. Read our full methodology →
Frequently asked questions
- Who is the #1 CPA in Staten Island?
- Arlia & Associates CPAs is currently the #1 ranked CPA firm in Staten Island based on our Guide Score, which evaluates Google reviews, credentials, press recognition, and professional presence. See the full ranked list above.
- How are CPAs ranked in Staten Island?
- Our Guide Score (0–100) combines Google rating (35%), review volume (20%), web and portfolio presence (20%), profile completeness (15%), professional credentials like CPA/EA/CMA (5%), press recognition (3%), and years of experience (2%). There is no paid placement.
- What do CPAs typically charge in Staten Island?
- Pricing varies by service and firm size. Individual tax returns in Staten Island commonly range from $200–$800; small business accounting packages run $500–$3,000/month; audit and advisory engagements are typically quoted per project. Each firm's profile page lists available services and contact information for quotes.