Best CPAs in Indianapolis, IN — 2026 Rankings
We ranked 8 CPA and accounting firms in Indianapolis based on credentials, client reviews, press recognition, and professional presence.
Top CPAs in Indianapolis
-
#1 — First Valley Accounting CPA Score: 44/100
First Valley Accounting CPA — Accounting And Tax in Indianapolis, IN
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#2 — Culwell Legal Score: 43/100
Culwell Legal — Accounting And Tax in Indianapolis, IN
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#3 — Merrill Lynch Wealth Management Score: 18/100
Merrill Lynch Wealth Management — Accounting And Tax in Indianapolis, IN
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#4 — Axia Advisory Score: 15/100
Axia Advisory — Accounting And Tax in Indianapolis, IN
Services: Business Advisory. View full profile →
-
#5 — Don Bowling Tax Score: 11/100
Don Bowling Tax
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#6 — 1-800Accountant - Indianapolis Score: 11/100
1-800Accountant - Indianapolis — Accounting And Tax in Indianapolis, IN
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
-
#7 — OnTarget CPA Score: 11/100
OnTarget CPA — Accounting And Tax in Indianapolis, IN
Services: Tax Preparation. View full profile →
-
#8 — Alerding CPA Group Score: 10/100
Alerding CPA Group — Accounting And Tax in Indianapolis, IN
Services: General Accounting. View full profile →
How We Rank CPAs & Accounting Firms
Our Guide Score (0–100) combines Google reviews (25%), professional credentials like CPA, EA, CMA, CIA, and CFP certifications (20%), press recognition (15%), review volume (15%), web and professional presence (10%), years of experience (10%), and profile completeness (5%). Read our full methodology →
Browse Indianapolis CPAs by service
Frequently asked questions
- Who is the #1 CPA in Indianapolis?
- First Valley Accounting CPA is currently the #1 ranked CPA firm in Indianapolis based on our Guide Score, which evaluates Google reviews, credentials, press recognition, and professional presence. See the full ranked list above.
- How are CPAs ranked in Indianapolis?
- Our Guide Score (0–100) combines Google reviews (25%), professional credentials like CPA, EA, CMA (20%), press recognition (15%), review volume (15%), web presence (10%), years of experience (10%), and profile completeness (5%). There is no paid placement.
- What do CPAs typically charge in Indianapolis?
- Pricing varies by service and firm size. Individual tax returns in Indianapolis commonly range from $200–$800; small business accounting packages run $500–$3,000/month; audit and advisory engagements are typically quoted per project. Each firm's profile page lists available services and contact information for quotes.