Best CPAs in Fishers, IN — 2026 Rankings

We ranked 9 CPA and accounting firms in Fishers based on credentials, client reviews, press recognition, and professional presence.

Top CPAs in Fishers

  1. #1 — Comer Nowling and Associates Score: 34/100

    Comer Nowling and Associates focuses on contact us, search site, services tax services, audit/attestation and serves clients throughout the Fishers, IN area. Their services include contact us, search site, services tax services, audit/attestation, consulting services.

    Services: Contact Us, Search Site, Services Tax Services, Audit/attestation, Consulting Services, Irs Representation, Industries, Monthly News, Financial Calculators, Life Event Library, Record Retention Guide, Tax Calendar, Fed State Tax Links, Finance Dictionary, Track Your Refund, Cartoon, Pay Your Bill, Our Team, Our History, Our Credentials, Our Areas of Specialization, Firm Photo Gallery, Services Audit/attestation, Tax Services Irs Representation, Small Business Services, Consulting, Reserve Studies, Industries Multi Family Affordable Housing, Nonprofit Organizations, Community Associations. View full profile →

  2. #2 — NSO and Company Score: 30/100

    CPA Accountant Indianapolis

    Services: Quick Links, Resources, Contact us, Services Accounting, Business Consulting, Tax Services, Pricing, Resources Tax Resources, Dates, Client Portal, Leave A Review, Client Portfolio, Bi Weekly, semi Monthly, and monthly payroll preparation, Payroll taxes remittances on your behalf as they are due, Monthly, quarterly, and annual federal and state payroll returns preparation ( 941, WH 1, UC 1, 940 and W2s.), 1099 preparation, Online access to all your payroll records, Employee vs. Subcontractors due diligence and determination., Employee Handbook, Labor Posters, Performance reviews, 1099 NEC, 1099 MISC, 1099 DIV, 1099 INT, Buying and selling a business consultation, Exit strategy, Business purchase due diligence preparation and reporting, Best practices for new businesses, Business and tax deductions. View full profile →

  3. #3 — Liftbridge Score: 29/100

    Fractional Finance & Accounting Services

    Services: Services Expand Fractional CFO Services, Mentoring, Nonprofit CFO, Outsourced Accounting, SaaS CFO, SBIC Fund CFO Services, Services Outsourced Accounting, Fractional CFO Services, Nonprofit CFO Services, SaaS Fractional CFO, Indianapolis Fractional CFO, Disclaimer, Services Toggle child menu Expand Fractional CFO Services. View full profile →

  4. #4 — Smith CPA Group Score: 29/100

    Smith CPA Group

    Services: Services, Business Tax Preparation, Tax Accounting Services for Business, Virtual CFO Services, Individual Tax Services, Business Filing (Schedule C), Individual Income Tax Return, Quarterly Estimated Taxes, Email Support Throughout the Year, $2,500/yr, Corporate or Partnership Tax Return, Year End Tax Planning, Quarterly Estimated Tax Payments, Email and phone support throughout the year, Starting at $350/mo, Monthly Bookkeeping, Starting at $550/mo, Starting at $750/mo, Rapid Business Growth, Falling Behind on Accounting, Uncertainty with Financial Management, Need for Real Time Financial Information, Too Much Time on Accounting, Find cost savings in operations, with vendors, and management, Find tax savings, Create a fiscal safety net, Properly manage payroll, Avoid penalties that result from inaccuracies and missing deadlines, Advise owners. View full profile →

  5. #5 — Rektio Accounting Score: 26/100

    Home • Rektio Entrepreneurial Advisors

    Services: View More Services, Accounting Back Office Services Rektio Entrepreneurial Advisors (463) 215 0968 Services Outsource Accounting, Accounting Back Office, Quickbooks Online Management, Other Services, Bookkeeping: Comprehensive and strategic bookkeeping that goes beyond mere data entry, focusing on insights and accuracy., AR Management: Proactive accounts receivable strategies to optimize cash flow and maintain healthy client relationships., AP Management: Efficient handling of payables, ensuring timely payments and optimizing your cash outflows., Payroll: Streamlined payroll processes that ensure accuracy and compliance, keeping your team satisfied and focused., Financial Reporting: Clear, actionable financial reports that provide the insights you need to make informed business decisions., Outsource Accounting, Taxes, Outsource CFO, Manage options, Manage services, Manage {vendor Count} vendors, {title}. View full profile →

  6. #6 — Stephens and Soetenga Score: 24/100

    Stephens & Soetenga, CPAs

    Services: General Accounting. View full profile →

  7. #7 — Long & Associates PC Score: 23/100

    Long & Associates PC

    Services: Consulting Services, Business Entity Selection, Business Consulting, Business Succession Planning, Business Valuations, Buying Selling a Business, Estate Planning, Accounting Software Selection Implementation, Investment Review, Pension Profit Sharing Plans, Other Services, Certified Quickbooks Pro Advisor, Litigation Support, Mergers Acquisitions, Notary Public, Accounting Services, Financial Forecasts Projections, Bookkeeping/Write Up, Cash Flow Budgeting Analysis, Audits, Reviews and Compilations, Tax Services, Tax Planning Preparation, IRS Representation, Payroll Services, Estate Trust Tax Preparation, Miscellaneous, QuickBooks Training and Set Up, Firm Profile, Client Services, Info Center. View full profile →

  8. #8 — RYR Accounting & Business Consulting Score: 21/100

    RYR Accounting & Business Consulting, an accounting firm in Fishers, IN, focuses on quality and client satisfaction. Their services include services, crypto, online payment, more. Reach them at +13175610222 or email richryu@ryrabc.com.

    Services: Services, Crypto, Online Payment, More. View full profile →

  9. #9 — Jerri Goben & Associates Score: 19/100

    Need an accounting firm in the Fishers area? Jerri Goben & Associates can be reached at +13178454483 or via their website for consultations.

    Services: Services, Resources Financial Calculators, Record Retention Guide, IRS Publications, IRS Forms, Tax Appointment Checklist, Tax Rates, Tax Due Dates, Taxpayer Rights, Tax Glossary, IRS Withholding Calculator, Where is My Refund?, Client Portal, Make a Payment, Request Appointment, Share Testimonial, Accounting Software Selection Implementation, Bookkeeping/Write Up, Business Consulting, Business Entity Selection, Estate Trust Tax Preparation, Financial Analysis, Financial Statements, IRS Representation, Notary Public, Sales Tax Services, Tax Preparation Planning. View full profile →

How We Rank CPAs & Accounting Firms

Our Guide Score (0–100) combines Google rating (35%), review volume (20%), web and portfolio presence (20%), profile completeness (15%), professional credentials like CPA/EA/CMA (5%), press recognition (3%), and years of experience (2%). Read our full methodology →

Frequently asked questions

Who is the #1 CPA in Fishers?
Comer Nowling and Associates is currently the #1 ranked CPA firm in Fishers based on our Guide Score, which evaluates Google reviews, credentials, press recognition, and professional presence. See the full ranked list above.
How are CPAs ranked in Fishers?
Our Guide Score (0–100) combines Google rating (35%), review volume (20%), web and portfolio presence (20%), profile completeness (15%), professional credentials like CPA/EA/CMA (5%), press recognition (3%), and years of experience (2%). There is no paid placement.
What do CPAs typically charge in Fishers?
Pricing varies by service and firm size. Individual tax returns in Fishers commonly range from $200–$800; small business accounting packages run $500–$3,000/month; audit and advisory engagements are typically quoted per project. Each firm's profile page lists available services and contact information for quotes.